Home » Media » Product News » Troubleshooting Organic Bentonite in Coatings & Inks: From “No Gel” To Seed Gels And Syneresis

Troubleshooting Organic Bentonite in Coatings & Inks: From “No Gel” To Seed Gels And Syneresis

Views: 0     Author: Site Editor     Publish Time: 2025-08-28      Origin: Site

Inquire

facebook sharing button
twitter sharing button
line sharing button
wechat sharing button
linkedin sharing button
pinterest sharing button
whatsapp sharing button
sharethis sharing button

Organic bentonite plays a crucial role in non-aqueous formulations, ensuring optimal rheology, suspension stability, and product performance. At Zhejiang Qinghong New Material Co., Ltd., we have specialized in producing high-quality organic bentonite since 1980, providing solutions that help formulators overcome common gel failures. Understanding the precise cause of a viscosity or suspension issue is the first step to restoring performance and achieving consistent results in coatings, inks, and related applications. Many laboratories struggle with achieving consistent gel strength, particularly when scaling up from lab to pilot production, making troubleshooting guidelines essential for both experienced and new formulators.

A systematic approach starts with careful observation: whether the issue is poor thickening, uneven dispersion, or delayed gel development, each symptom points to specific root causes. By identifying these causes early, formulators can save significant time and reduce waste while improving overall product quality. With organic bentonite sourced from Zhejiang Qinghong, which meets rigorous industry standards, laboratories can rely on reproducible performance even under challenging conditions.

 

Activation and Order-of-Addition Errors

One of the most common causes of rheology problems in formulations using organic bentonite is improper activation. Polar activators are essential for organoclay to develop its gel structure, but errors in timing or quantity can drastically affect performance. Under-activation often occurs when too little activator is added or when it is introduced too late in the mixing process, resulting in a “no gel” scenario where the suspension fails to thicken or maintain stability. Over-activation, on the other hand, can cause viscosity drops and thin, unstable formulations.

To prevent under-activation, it is recommended to follow a precise stepwise procedure: first, pre-wet the organoclay with a compatible solvent, then gradually add the polar activator while maintaining moderate shear. Monitoring the gelation progress using a viscometer can provide real-time feedback and ensure optimal activation. Over-activation can be mitigated by carefully measuring the polar activator and avoiding excessive quantities.

Another critical factor is the choice of solvent during activation. Selecting the wrong solvent or introducing the activator in an incompatible medium can prevent proper wetting of the clay and disrupt the formation of the gel network. Solvents with very low or very high polarity can either under-swell the clay or destabilize the gel, respectively. Small-scale pre-gel testing in the lab, sometimes called a “seed gel trial,” allows formulators to fine-tune solvent selection and activator concentration, providing a reliable template for scale-up.

 Organic Bentonite

Shear and Dispersion Problems

Even with correct activation, insufficient shear or improper dispersion can hinder the performance of organic bentonite. The gel network requires adequate mechanical energy to unfold and distribute the organoclay platelets evenly. Using a low-shear impeller or mixing at the wrong speed may lead to poorly dispersed particles, resulting in streaks, clumps, or weak gels. Conversely, excessive shear can break down the clay structure, causing permanent viscosity loss.

A practical approach is to start with low-to-moderate shear and gradually increase energy input while observing gel consistency. Impeller type and tank geometry also play a critical role in dispersion. For instance, high-viscosity formulations may benefit from a side-entering impeller that creates uniform flow, minimizing dead zones where clay could remain undispersed. Temperature monitoring is equally important, as organoclays are sensitive to heat: excessive temperatures can accelerate unwanted chemical interactions or evaporate critical solvents, leading to gel collapse.

 

Incompatibilities with Resin and Additives

Formulations often contain multiple additives, including resins, surfactants, and wetting agents, which can interact with organic bentonite and interfere with gel formation. Adding wetting agents too early in the process may coat the clay platelets, reducing their ability to swell and form a network. Certain surfactants or defoamers can also destabilize the organoclay, leading to syneresis, settling, or inconsistent viscosity.

To isolate incompatibilities, A/B testing is highly recommended. Introduce one additive at a time and monitor its effect on viscosity, gel strength, and particle suspension. For resins, consider the polarity and solvent compatibility: highly polar resins may hinder organoclay activation, while nonpolar resins generally have minimal interference. Additionally, timing adjustments—adding sensitive additives only after the clay network is fully developed—can prevent early-stage conflicts, ensuring the gel performs as intended.

 

Storage Stability Issues

Even a well-activated, well-dispersed formulation can encounter stability problems during storage. Common phenomena include syneresis, pigment float, and rebound settling, all of which can reduce the perceived quality of the product. Syneresis occurs when excess liquid separates from the gel over time, while pigment float may result from insufficient gel strength to suspend heavier particles.

Preventive strategies include optimizing organoclay concentration based on pigment load and application type, as well as confirming complete activation during production. Incorporating controlled QC checkpoints for storage stability, such as accelerated aging tests or freeze-thaw cycles, helps identify potential failures before the product reaches customers. Using high-quality organic bentonite from Zhejiang Qinghong ensures consistent long-term performance, even in challenging storage environments.

 

Quick Bench Tests That Save Pilot Time

To minimize trial-and-error at scale, formulators can rely on quick bench tests to assess gel quality and predict long-term performance. The pre-gel cup test allows rapid observation of initial swelling and viscosity development. Sag bar ladders provide insight into anti-settling performance, while 24–72 hour jar tests reveal potential syneresis or pigment float issues. Viscosity loop testing, where shear is applied and then removed, simulates real-world application conditions and helps confirm gel robustness.

Additional practical tests include measuring thixotropic recovery, which evaluates how well a gel recovers its structure after shear, and using optical observation to detect flocculation or micro-settling. These simple yet effective tests allow teams to make informed adjustments before committing to full-scale production, saving significant time and material costs.

 

Conclusion

A systematic approach to troubleshooting organic bentonite ensures that formulations meet performance expectations consistently. By carefully managing activation, dispersion, additive compatibility, and storage conditions, formulators can transform “no gel” situations into stable, reproducible seed gels and prevent syneresis. Zhejiang Qinghong New Material Co., Ltd. continues to offer high-performance organic bentonite that supports coatings, inks, and other critical applications, enabling reliable rheology, enhanced suspension stability, and consistent product quality. Contact us to learn more about how our organic bentonite solutions can optimize your formulations, reduce production risks, and enhance overall efficiency.

Sign Up for Our Newsletter

Adhering to the enterprise's spirit of "Encourage ourselves to achieve ambition, seek truth and make progress".
Zhejiang Qinghong New Material Co., Ltd. is a professional manufacturer of organic bentonite since 1980.

QUICK LINKS

PRODUCTS

CONTACT US

Zaoxi Industrial Park, Tianmushan Town, Lin'An City, Zhejiang, China
 +86-571-63781600
Copyright © 2024 Zhejiang Qinghong New Material Co., Ltd. Sitemap 浙ICP备05074532号-1